'Magic monks' face harsh reality in Thailand
Scientists on a mission to debunk the superstitions and sometimes fraudulent powers that have a stranglehold on Thai society.
 |
| |
| A monk with magical tattoos on his back sits at a Buddhist
monastery in Bangkok. Age-old beliefs in everything from ghosts to
lucky charms continue to be widely accepted by Thais. (Photo by Tibor
Krausz/ucanews.com) |
Bangkok:
Wat Cha-ang on the northern outskirts of Bangkok boasts an old
Buddha statue whose origins date back to the era of the Thai capital
city's founding in the late 18th century.
Yet that's not why
people from far and wide have been flocking to the Buddhist monastery in
a riverside community on a bank of the Chao Phraya River. The object of
most visitors' interest is an old tree trunk.
The trunk was
fished out of the river two years ago after an elderly monk, since
deceased, had a dream in which a female arboreal spirit told him of the
dead tree lying underwater nearby and asked him to help retrieve it from
its watery grave.
Or so locals believe.
"We found the
trunk submerged in water," recalls Chalerm Tongmorn, a local man who now
guards the trunk, which many Thais believe to have belonged to a sacred
tree once growing by the river. "It was there on the opposite bank," he
adds with a hand gesture indicating the place.
"The tree trunk
was pointing in the direction of the temple, against the current. It was
showing us where it wanted to be taken."
Taken to the monastery, the trunk has been on display at a specially built teakwood pavilion ever since.
The
sacred tree trunk's storied discovery and alleged magical powers have
been drawing a steady stream of visitors who come with gifts and
donations in the hope of being rewarded with good fortune.
Most
supplicants seek to be shown winning lottery numbers. These they hope to
find out by rubbing talcum powder on the off-white trunk and looking
for number-shaped patters in it. Some of the people who have visited the
shrine have reportedly won the lottery.
However, those with the
most to gain from the venerated trunk's presence are clearly local
monks. Wat Cha-ang has received several million baht in donations,
resident monks say.
"Thais have strong beliefs about sacred
trees," says Wipat Pathumkij, the monastery's abbot. "When people hear
about this tree [trunk], they come and come. They want to see. They
believe they will get lucky."
Local monks do not discourage such beliefs.
"In
Buddhism we should only believe in things that we can prove," the abbot
acknowledges. "But it's part of Thai culture to believe in spirits. I
don't want to scold people for placing their trust in supernatural
things."
Yet scientifically minded Thais see the continued
stranglehold of superstitions on Thais from all walks of life as
something of a curse.
"How can we become a modern society if
people continue to believe in nonsense?" asks Jessada Denduangboripant, a
biologist who lectures at Chulalongkorn University in Bangkok.
An
energetic man in his early 40s, Jessada is a science popularizer on a
mission. He's been waging a one-man crusade against self-styled mystics
and miracle-mongers who set out to strike it rich by deceiving gullible
Thais.
The scientist has especially had it in for Buddhist monks
who claim to possess miraculous powers or peddle what they pass off as
supernatural phenomena. On his widely popular YouTube channel called
Wittaya Tasawang ("Open Your Eyes With Science"), Jessada has debunked
the stunts of several self-styled saffron-robed miracle workers, showing
them to be cheap tricks.
His targets included monks at a
monastery in the northeastern province of Nong Bua Lamphu who came to
fame two years ago when some began performing what seemed to be
miraculous deeds.
The monks would sit down in a meditative pose
within large vats of oil, under which attendants then light a pile of
wood. Despite the intense heat, the monks appear unperturbed and
unharmed as they continue meditating.
Donations from the faithful
— mostly poor rural folk — started pouring in. The Buddhist temple also
began making a brisk business selling mass-produced talismans and small
bottles of "sacred oil," which were touted as potions with magical
medicinal properties.
Jessada was skeptical. The vats the monks
used, he noticed from watching a YouTube video, had an odd shape: a
large flat rim was attached to a round bowl. The containers, he
surmised, had an inner layer for insulation, which allowed the monks to
remain unaffected by the heat.
He demonstrated how it was done in
a simple science experiment in his lab and went on Thai television to
debunk the alleged miracle performed by the "magic monks."
"I am a
practicing Buddhist, but I believe it's my job to help expose monks
like these," Jessada says. "They bring discredit on my religion by
deceiving people."
He has his work cut out for him. Numerous
monks around Thailand, a country where age-old superstitions continue to
proliferate, claim to have magical abilities.
In the southern
province of Nakhon Si Thammarat, a Buddhist monk called Phra Ajarn Cha
("Venerable Teacher Cha") shot to fame not long ago after he claimed
that he could sweat red crystals.
Because of his great spiritual
accomplishments and moral character, it was claimed, his beads of sweat
and drops of blood miraculously morphed into crystals. These "sacred
relics" came to be coveted as protective talismans by his followers,
many of whom paid large sums of money to acquire some of them.
Yet this monk too turned out to be a swindler.
Weerachai
Phutdhawong, an associate professor of organic chemistry at Kasetsart
University in Bangkok, got hold of a few "magic crystals" allegedly
perspired by the holy man and tested them in his lab. They were common
plastic beads.
The monk wasn't amused. "He started threatening
me," recalls Weerachai, who is a practicing Buddhist. "Monks like him
sell belief in themselves and use tricks as signs of their spiritual
powers."
Yet the monks do not themselves create Thais'
unquestioning belief in an unseen world of magic and mystery. Rather,
they simply tap into a dense miasma of superstition that continues to
permeate Thai society from top to bottom. Age-old beliefs in everything
from ghosts to lucky charms continue to be widely credited by locals.
Magic
tattoos are believed to protect their wearers from various forms of
physical harm and spiritual misfortune. Strange occurrences are presumed
to hold clues about winning lottery numbers. Animals like cobras are
taken to be manifestations of supernatural beings like mythical Naga
serpents: when they trespass into homes they are welcomed as harbingers
of good fortune.
When locals do not understand puzzling natural phenomena, they reflexively attribute supernatural causes to them.
Jessada
wants to help change that. The university lecturer has been travelling
around the Thai countryside, visiting primary schools and high schools
to explain the benefits of skepticism and scientific methods to
students.
"We can teach young people to seek evidence for their
beliefs and not to take everything at face value," he explains. "That
way they will be far less credulous when they grow up."
Source:
UCAN