Tuesday, 27 November 2018

Repatriation of the Rohingya: Real deal or mind game?

Repatriation of the Rohingya: Real deal or mind game?

Muslim minority have become pawns in diplomatic game between Myanmar and Bangladesh.

 

By Rock Ronald Rozario
Dhaka:  The failed attempt to send 150 refugees out of over one million currently residing in overcrowded camps in Cox's Bazar back to Rakhine State in Myanmar was the first concrete step for their repatriation.

The problem is that none of those in the first batch of 2,260 refugees due to be sent home were willing to go. Most of them responded by fleeing their temporary shelters and going into hiding. Others held daylong protests opposing the repatriation move.

Dhaka has been working enthusiastically to return the Rohingya to Myanmar but the deal has been delayed several times after a repatriation deal was signed in January of this year.

The first deal, inked without any third party involvement, sparked an international outcry.

Bangladesh, one of the world's most densely populated and impoverished nations, was forced to sign the deal as it creaks under the weight of domestic pressures including a shortage of resources. Finding more resources to feed some one million refugees has invited a backlash from many Bangladeshis.

Yet the deal failed to defuse the mounting international criticism of Myanmar's handling of the crisis. It did not include third party oversight and, importantly, lacked any input from those at the center of the crisis — the Rohingya.

That being said, none of the deals signed so far have taken into account the key concerns and demands of the Rohingya, including calls for justice over the atrocities they have suffered, the return of their property, reparations for the damage done, and the right to citizenship in Myanmar.

While Buddhists in Rakhine have strongly opposed any return of the Rohingya, Myanmar decided to accommodate the returnees in camps, much to their consternation.

Moreover, it will take years to rebuild the hundreds of Rohingya villages that were razed and fully resettle the returnees.

Yet it pressed ahead with the repatriation plan to spare itself more global criticism, looming sanctions, a faltering economy, and also to reduce pressure from its longtime ally and backer, China.

China and India have reportedly promised to pay for hundreds of houses for the refugees. The two regional rivals both have huge investments in Bangladesh that they are unlikely to let go of.

China also has a lot of financial sway over Myanmar's economy. China needs Myanmar to help realize the completion of its much-hyped Belt and Road Initiative, and it also cannot ignore an emerging regional economy like Bangladesh.

It is worth noting here that the first list of refugees to be repatriated only included Muslims, not the 500 or so Hindu refugees who are eager to get back to Myanmar.

Given the political and diplomatic dimensions of the deal, it was unlikely to be implemented in such a tense political atmosphere ahead of the polls.

The problem is that successive military rulers in Myanmar, and now its civilian government and hard-line Buddhists, have repeatedly made it known that the Rohingya are not welcome and they don't want the refugees to return.

Without a consensus-based deal, the repatriation of the Rohingya will remain elusive and unrealistic, leaving them as pawns in a diplomatic game being played out between two neighboring nations, and ultimately prolonging their misery and hardship.

Rock Ronald Rozario is a Dhaka-based journalist, writer and Bangladesh Bureau Chief for ucanews.com

Source: UCAN

ROBERT JOHN KENNEDY: Asia Bibi protest leader arrested in Pakistan

ROBERT JOHN KENNEDY: Asia Bibi protest leader arrested in Pakistan: Asia Bibi protest leader arrested in Pakistan Violence breaks out in Lahore after Tehreek-e-Labbaik chief is held in protective c...

Asia Bibi protest leader arrested in Pakistan

Asia Bibi protest leader arrested in Pakistan

Violence breaks out in Lahore after Tehreek-e-Labbaik chief is held in protective custody by police.

 
File photo
Karachi:  Pakistan has launched a crackdown on a religious group who paralyzed the country for three days after the acquittal of Catholic death row inmate Asia Bibi.

Bibi, a mother of five who had been held in solitary confinement on death row since 2010, had her blasphemy conviction overturned by the Supreme Court on Oct. 30.

The court's ruling sparked three days of violent protests led by Khadim Hussain Rizvi, the firebrand cleric and chief of Tehreek-e-Labbaik Pakistan (TLP), a politico-religious group known for its staunch support of draconian blasphemy laws.

The protests prompted the government to sign a controversial deal that drew condemnation from minority and human rights groups.

The Christian woman was eventually released on Nov. 8 in Multan and flown to Islamabad. Her whereabouts have been kept secret due to threats to her life and her family.

On Nov. 23, police, rangers and other law enforcement agencies detained Rizvi and hundreds of his followers in an undeclared crackdown against the group. The move sparked clashes between Rizvi's supporters and police in Lahore in which at least five people were injured.

Government spokesman Fawad Chaudhry said Rizvi was taken into protective custody after he announced plans to hold a rally in Rawalpindi.

"Khadim Hussain Rizvi has been taken into protective custody by police and shifted to a guesthouse. They insisted on coming to Rawalpindi and refused the government's proposal for alternative arrangements," Chaudhry said shortly after the arrests.

"The government did its best to convince them but they refused every offer and started to provoke violence. The public are requested to stay peaceful and calm. The law shall take its course and it cannot be left to individuals."

In a press statement on Nov. 25, TLP Karachi head Allama Razi Hussaini said the group was being punished for staging protests against Bibi's acquittal.

"Our more than 500 leaders and workers have been missing ever since the crackdown was launched by the police," Hussaini said.

He also condemned the house arrest of Islamic scholar Mufti Muneeb ur Rehman for his support of the TLP.

Bibi was sentenced to death in 2010 on charges of making derogatory remarks about the Prophet Muhammad during an argument with a Muslim farm worker.

Her lawyer Saiful Malook has fled Pakistan after threats to his life.

The raw video below shows TLP supporters clashing with police at Numaish Chowrangi in Karachi on Nov. 24. (Video courtesy of TLP media)

Source: UCAN

ROBERT JOHN KENNEDY: Scams in Jan Dhan, Ujjwala schemes will be unearth...

ROBERT JOHN KENNEDY: Scams in Jan Dhan, Ujjwala schemes will be unearth...: Scams in Jan Dhan, Ujjwala schemes will be unearthed in future: Mamata Terming the BJP and RSS as worshippers of the demon king R...

Scams in Jan Dhan, Ujjwala schemes will be unearthed in future: Mamata

Scams in Jan Dhan, Ujjwala schemes will be unearthed in future: Mamata

Terming the BJP and RSS as worshippers of the demon king Ravana, the Trinamool Congress supremo accused them of selling their Gods to get votes.

 
Mamata Banerjee. (File Photo: IANS)
Kolkata:  Claiming that the scandals in the BJP-led NDA government have come out in the open due to disputes within the Central Bureau of Investigation and the Reserve Bank of India, West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Monday said more wrongdoings by the Centre will be unearthed in the future.

Banerjee claimed that there are scams within the central government schemes like the 'Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana', that aims to provide affordable access to financial services, and the 'Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana' under which LPG subsidy is being provided.

"They (Centre) are busy looting people's money and scamming them in every way possible. Today, the cat is out of the bag due to the ongoing CBI and RBI controversies. In coming days, same things would happen in the Jan Dhan accounts or in case of LPG subsidy," Banerjee said at a public rally in Jhargram district.

All the development in this region has been done by the state government. But some parties come here with bags of cash and alcohol before the elections and ask for people's votes.

"You can take the money if you need it, but do not vote for them. Remember, the money they are distributing is not theirs, it is common man's money," she said in a veiled reference to the Bharatiya Janata Party.

The saffron outfit has increased its strength considerably in the tribal belt of Bengal, especially Jhargram, where it gained a majority in the last Gram Panchayat elections.

Terming the BJP and the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) as worshippers of the demon king Ravana, the Trinamool Congress supremo accused them of selling their Gods to get votes.

"They worship Ravana, not lord Ram. They sell their Gods to get votes. That's why they stoke fire of unrest in the country. We do not do that. Our Gods and Goddesses are like our mother," Banerjee said.

Banerjee said that her government also provides special assistance to the people of Maoist-infested Jangalmahal, comprising Bengal's western districts including Jhargram, and urged people to drive away the forces that practise division and intolerance.

"Those who spread false propaganda, try to divide people, and dictate terms on the basis of religion should be ashamed. Where were they when the people of Jangalamahal used to spend their life in fear? When the youths used to get killed at the hands of Maoists or get arrested by the police everyday?" Banerjee said.

"I urge the 'Kanyashrees' (girls) to convince their parents, family and children not to be with the divisive forces," she added.

IANS

ROBERT JOHN KENNEDY: Hindu groups revive demand for controversial Ram t...

ROBERT JOHN KENNEDY: Hindu groups revive demand for controversial Ram t...: Hindu groups revive demand for controversial Ram temple Pro-Hindu Bharatiya Janata Party has been using emotive Ayodhya issue to ...

Hindu groups revive demand for controversial Ram temple

Hindu groups revive demand for controversial Ram temple

Pro-Hindu Bharatiya Janata Party has been using emotive Ayodhya issue to garner votes, say critics.

 
Sadhus and monks were part of a dharma sabha (religious meeting) in Ayodhya in the Indian state of Uttar Pradesh on Nov. 25. They gathered to revive a decade-old demand to build a temple on land that once had a Muslim mosque. Hindu hardliners destroyed the mosque in 1992. (Photo by IANS)
New Delhi:  Tens of thousands of Hindus gathered in the northern Indian city of Ayodhya on Nov. 26 to demand a Hindu temple be built where a mosque once stood before it was demolished by Hindu hardliners more than two decades ago.

An estimated 200,000 Hindus gathered in the city for a dharam sabha (religious meeting) to pressure Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his pro-Hindu Bharatiya Janata Party-led government to build a Ram temple at the site of the 16th century Babri mosque which Hindu hardliners destroyed on Dec. 6, 1992.

A temple cannot be built as a dispute between Muslims and Hindus over who controls the land continues in the courts.

Hindu groups say they have proposed designs for a temple and are ready to build a temple.

"We will not sit in ease until temple construction is achieved," said Krishna Gopal, a leader of Hindu umbrella organization RSS (Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh) who chaired the meeting.

Hindus consider Ayodhya in Uttar Pradesh state the birthplace of Hindu lord Ram. They claim Mughal ruler Babar demolished a Ram temple and built over it with the mosque. Hard-line Hindu groups stress the land originally belonged to them.

The 1992 mosque destruction triggered Hindu-Muslim riots that killed some 2,000 people nationwide.

Before the large numbers arrived on Nov. 26, hundreds of Muslims fled the city fearing violence as the anniversary of the demolition was barely a week away.

The BJP has been accused of engineering the 1992 demolition and its action is seen as helping push the BJP to political prominence and eventually take power in Delhi.

The BJP said the mosque was an insult to Hindu self-esteem and its past party slogans said only a Ram temple at the place of mosque could help revive Hindu pride.

In the past six general elections since the demolition, the BJP promised a Ram temple would be built in Ayodhya but failed to deliver.

Critics say the Hindu party has been using the emotive issue purely to garner votes.

"The RSS-BJP is trying to set the country on fire by raking the temple issue. At a time when people need jobs, food and economic well-being, it is a huge distraction from the failures being created by the BJP," Marxist leader Sitaram Yechury told the media.

Another prominent opposition leader, Akhilesh Yadav of the socialist Samajwadi Party, said the BJP is attempting to divert people's attention from the Modi government's "big-time failures."

Muslim trader Nassim Haque in Ahmedabad told ucanews.com that the main opposition Congress party — which traditionally enjoyed Muslim support — has taken an approach of "soft Hindutuva," meaning a soft appeasement of Hindus.

Haque gave the example of how opposition parties and Muslim groups used to observe protest meetings on the anniversary of the Babri mosque demolition.

"A few years ago, the Congress party started playing their vanilla secularism and ordered that no such protest should be held," he said.

"Muslims are no longer wanted in this country. Everyone is after Hindu votes, so the temple movement is back."

Source: UCAN

Pope Leo XIV visits the St. Oscar Romero Chapel in Chiclayo, Peru

  Pope Leo XIV visits the St. Oscar Romero Chapel in Chiclayo, Peru During a brief private visit to the St. Oscar Romero Chapel in Chiclayo,...